ESGone?

How sustainable investing has come of age

Is sustainable investing coming to an end following the political headwinds of recent years? Or has it, precisely because of this, evolved from a morally driven investment style into an indispensable component of modern financial analysis?

Please note: investing in securities involves risks as well as opportunities.

ESG – from trend to taboo?

Just a few years ago, references to ESG and sustainability could not be mentioned often enough in many company reports and presentations. ESG strategies were presented, climate targets announced, and sustainability reports published, many of which rivalled annual reports in scope.

Then came the headwinds: in the United States in particular, ESG increasingly became a politically charged term, while in Europe the originally well-intentioned regulation grew ever more complex, turning every client meeting into a compulsory lecture on European sustainability regulation. Sustainable investing suddenly had an image problem – and the acronym ESG became a taboo term at many places.

However, anyone who concluded from this that sustainable investment was coming to an end had overlooked a key development: sustainable investment has long since become more than just a moral decision or a means of meeting regulatory requirements. It has become an additional research tool. Or to put it another way: ESG hasn’t disappeared; it has simply grown up.

From exclusion to selection

Sustainable investing was originally strongly influenced by ethical considerations. Quite a few people asked themselves: what business sectors do I not want to support with my money? For example, arms and tobacco are excluded from our sustainable investment strategies.

However, these considerations merely define where investors wish to draw the line. They say very little about a company’s economic success.

The key question has therefore broadened: Not just “In what companies do I not want to invest?”, but above all “What companies are best prepared for the challenges of the future?” This makes sustainability analysis an integral part of the fundamental investment decision.

Decarbonisation is a case in point: this is no longer simply the question of whether a company is reducing its CO₂ emissions sufficiently to combat the climate crisis. Rather, the crucial factor is the impact that rising energy costs, new technologies, investment requirements, physical risks at the production site, and changing customer demands will have on the company’s future profitability. 

“It is now virtually certain that the temperature in 2026 will be more than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels,” writes the EU’s Copernicus service in a press release. This will be the second time, after 2024, that this threshold has been exceeded, as the Statista chart illustrates. As a result, the Paris Agreement’s target of limiting the temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius appears increasingly unrealistic. What humanity can and is willing to do to counter climate change, will be discussed from 9 to 20 November at the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference in Antalya.

The same applies to water consumption, dependence on natural resources in general, and the recruitment of qualified staff. Specific questions also arise regarding corporate governance: How independent is the supervisory board? Do remuneration schemes provide incentives for long-term corporate success? How are risks and conflicts of interest managed, and how are shareholders’ rights protected?

Not every sustainability factor is equally important for every sector. A water supplier faces different risks than a bank does. In both cases, however, it is crucial that management recognises these risks and acts accordingly.

Forecasts are no reliable indicator of future developments. Data as of 09/11/2026

What do artificial intelligence and sustainability have in common? 

The financial significance of sustainability criteria is particularly evident in one of the biggest investment trends of the moment: artificial intelligence.

Data centres require not only high-performance chips, but above all enormous amounts of electricity and the corresponding cooling capacity. Depending on the technology used, water requirements can also be considerable. This is not just a question of the quantity available, but also of water quality and the costs of treatment. Particularly in regions facing water scarcity, these factors can become a critical bottleneck. The availability of these resources, connection to the electricity grid and acceptance by the local population can determine whether a planned data centre can be built at all and, subsequently, whether it will be commercially successful.

The governance of AI companies also deserves special attention: how are data protection and security guaranteed? Who bears responsibility for faulty systems? What liability risks might arise from this?

These are not questions that only particularly environmentally conscious or ethically motivated investors should be asking themselves. Rather, these are fundamental factors for the long-term financial success of these companies.

Sustainability does not, therefore, necessarily mean excluding certain sectors. Instead, it is about identifying, within a sector, those companies that are best placed to deal with future challenges.

ESGenius: three perspectives are better than one

A simple checklist is not enough to analyse these differences systematically. Industry-specific data, quantitative models, and experienced specialists are required.

At Erste Asset Management, we rely on our in-house developed ESGenius® Score, which rates companies on a scale of 0 to 100. The model combines the research efforts of three research providers – MSCI ESG Research, ISS ESG, and Clarity AI – into a single, consistent assessment.

These providers examine companies from different perspectives: financial sustainability risks, environmental and social impacts, as well as technology-driven analyses and controversies. The key factor here is the so-called best-in-class approach: companies are not compared across all sectors as a whole, but rather against their respective competitors.

In addition, we have developed our own specialised models. The Climate Transition Score, for example, examines current CO₂ emissions, progress made to date in decarbonisation, and the credibility of future climate targets. The Biodiversity Score focuses on dependence on natural resources and the impact of business activities on nature.

Where external data is lacking or does not adequately reflect a company’s actual situation, our specialists complement this with their own qualitative assessments carried out on a dual-review basis, based on the international SASB standard.

The aim is not to collect as much sustainability data as possible, but to derive relevant information from this data for investment decisions.

Not every sustainable fund has the same objective

The fact that sustainable investing is now much more nuanced than it used to be is also reflected in the structure of institutional mandates. At Erste Asset Management, we generally distinguish between three sustainable investment approaches:

  • Integration: Sustainability risks and opportunities are taken into account in the selection of securities in addition to traditional financial analysis. Companies with particularly high ESG risks are excluded. With the exception of arms, tobacco, and coal, there are no sector-specific exclusions.
  • Responsible: In addition to further exclusion criteria, more stringent requirements are applied to the sustainability assessment. Only those companies that rank amongst the best in their sector are considered investable.
  • Impact: Companies are selected on the basis of their sales volume, taking into account their environmental or social priorities. Unlike the market-wide strategies mentioned earlier, impact funds are highly focused thematic funds.

Depending on the mandate, sustainability criteria can influence the investment universe and portfolio weightings to varying degrees. This distinction is particularly relevant for institutional investors. A pension fund, for example, may have different requirements regarding exclusion criteria, climate risks, and portfolio structure than a retirement fund or an insurance company.

There is therefore no single “correct” approach to sustainability. The key is for sustainability objectives, risk appetite, and investment strategy to be aligned.

The current European product categories under Articles 8 and 9 of the Disclosure Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 November 2019 on sustainability‐related disclosures in the financial services sector) only partially reflect these differences. The SFDR reform proposed by the European Commission, with new categories for sustainable strategies, transition, and basic ESG approaches, could provide greater clarity in this regard in the future.

An opportunity for Europe? Sustainable bonds are in particularly high demand in Europe. This is one of the findings of an OECD report on sustainable bonds. According to the report, sustainable corporate bonds issued by non-financial companies accounted for 31% of all corporate bond issues in Europe from 2020 to 2024. For bonds issued by financial companies, the share stood at 13%.

Company dialogues are significantly more relevant than a “clean” portfolio

One point that is often misunderstood is the actual impact of sustainable investments. The vast majority of transactions – apart from new listings or new issues – take place on the so-called secondary market, between investors. Unlike with a bank loan, no fresh capital is provided to the company in this process.

The impact of sustainable investments therefore stems not primarily from the portfolio itself, but from the resulting dialogue with management and the exercise of voting rights at the annual general meetings of the companies in which investments are held. The leverage for change is particularly significant when voting rights are exercised even in traditional funds without an explicit sustainability focus, as Erste Asset Management has been doing for the past ten years.

In 2025, we voted at 670 annual general meetings of 606 companies. In 11.6% of the votes cast, we deliberately voted against management proposals. In addition, we engaged in numerous dialogues with companies on climate change, biodiversity, working conditions, and corporate governance.

On governance issues in particular, investors can demand specific improvements – such as more independent supervisory boards, better remuneration systems, or greater transparency. We report on this in detail, using specific company examples, in our annual Engagement and Voting Report.

The US midterms: blue is not automatically green

Back to politics: In a blog post from February, Walter Hatak had asked whether Donald Trump could actually continue his anti-renewable-energy stance in the face of rising energy costs and the upcoming mid-term elections. The voters have now spoken: in the US mid-term elections on 3 November 2026, the Democrats won a majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.

Does this mean a return to previous US climate policy? Hardly. Donald Trump remains president and still has his right of veto. However, from January 2027, the new Congress will be able to exercise significantly greater control over his energy policy and make it more difficult for Trump to push through new initiatives against the Congress’s will.

It is interesting to note that it was not primarily moral debates on climate change, but rather high living and energy costs that played a key role in the election. Even in the United States, this brings the economic dimension of the energy transition more sharply into focus.

Europe, too, has significantly scaled back its sustainability regulations in 2026 with the Omnibus Package. However, fewer reporting obligations do not mean that companies will suddenly consume less energy, require less water, or no longer face risks arising from poor corporate governance.

Regulatory requirements may change. The underlying economic realities remain the same.

ESGone? More like ESGrown-up!

Sustainable investing does not automatically lead to better performance; particularly in less diversified markets, such as in Europe, the exclusion of defence-related sectors – as it was the case last year – can detract from performance.

However, taking financially relevant sustainability criteria into account can help to identify risks at an earlier stage, compare companies more effectively, and make more informed investment decisions in the long term. An internal study by our risk management experts has shown that, over a 10-year period, our sustainability selection resulted in significant outperformance.

In our view, this is precisely where the future of sustainable investing lies: moving away from blanket promises, ever-more-extensive checklists and the mere fulfilment of regulatory requirements – towards better research, more nuanced stock selection and consistent active ownership.

Perhaps there will be less talk of ESG in future. In the investment process, however, it is likely to become all the more a matter of course.

So, ESG isn’t gone. It has just grown up.

For explanations of technical terms, please visit our Fund Glossary.

Disclaimer

This document is an advertisement. Please refer to the prospectus of the UCITS or to the Information for Investors pursuant to Art 21 AIFMG of the alternative investment fund and the Key Information Document before making any final investment decisions. All data is sourced from Erste Asset Management GmbH, unless indicated otherwise. Our languages of communication are German and English.

The prospectus for UCITS (including any amendments) is published in accordance with the provisions of the InvFG 2011 in the currently amended version. Information for Investors pursuant to Art 21 AIFMG is prepared for the alternative investment funds (AIF) administered by Erste Asset Management GmbH pursuant to the provisions of the AIFMG in connection with the InvFG 2011.

The fund prospectus, Information for Investors pursuant to Art 21 AIFMG, and the Key Information Document can be viewed in their latest versions at the website www.erste-am.com within the section mandatory publications  or obtained in their latest versions free of charge from the domicile of the management company and the domicile of the custodian bank. The exact date of the most recent publication of the fund prospectus, the languages in which the fund prospectus or the Information for Investors pursuant to Art  21 AIFMG and the Key Information Document are available, and any additional locations where the documents can be obtained can be viewed on the website www.erste-am.com. A summary of investor rights is available in German and English on the website www.erste-am.com/investor-rights as well as at the domicile of the management company.

The management company can decide to revoke the arrangements it has made for the distribution of unit certificates abroad, taking into account the regulatory requirements.

Detailed information on the risks potentially associated with the investment can be found in the fund prospectus or Information for investors pursuant to Art 21 AIFMG of the respective fund. If the fund currency is a currency other than the investor's home currency, changes in the corresponding exchange rate may have a positive or negative impact on the value of his investment and the amount of the costs incurred in the fund - converted into his home currency.

Our analyses and conclusions are general in nature and do not take into account the individual needs of our investors in terms of earnings, taxation, and risk appetite. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of the future performance of a fund.

The issue and redemption of unit certificates and the execution of payments to unit holders has been transferred to the Fund's custodian bank/depositary, Erste Group Bank AG, Am Belvedere 1, 1100 Vienna, Austria. Redemption requests can be submitted by investors to their custodian bank, which will forward them to the Custodian Bank/Depositary of the Fund for execution via the usual banking channels. All payments to investors are also processed via the usual banking clearing channel with the investor's custodian bank. In Germany, the issue and return prices of shares are published in electronic form on the web site www.erste-am.com (and also at www.fundinfo.com). Any other information for Shareholders is published in the Bundesanzeiger, Cologne. 

Weitere OUR VIEW Beiträge lesen